Water Heater Cost Calculator
Compare a heat pump, gas tankless, gas tank, and electric water heater on upfront, operating, and lifetime cost, at your rates and climate, with the IRA credit.
Your inputs stay in your browser. We never see them.
Household & Location
Equipment Costs (Installed)
Incentive
Lowest 10-year cost
Heat pump water heater
$4,254
over 10 yrIt costs more upfront than the cheapest option, but recovers that gap in about 1 year at these inputs.
All four options, ranked by 10-year total cost
Net upfront
$1,750
To run / year
$224
Energy / year
798 kWh
Net upfront
$1,500
To run / year
$381
Energy / year
159 therms
Net upfront
$3,500
To run / year
$254
Energy / year
106 therms
Net upfront
$1,300
To run / year
$850
Energy / year
3,037 kWh
Lifetime cost is net upfront (after the HPWH credit, if applied) plus operating cost over 10 years, with each fuel escalated at its own rate. Recommended sizes are starting points; confirm sizing with an installer.
Why a heat pump can run cheaper
A heat pump water heater moves heat instead of making it. At these inputs its effective COP of 3.5 means it delivers about 3.5 units of heat per unit of electricity, so it runs cheaper than an electric resistance tank here. Whether it beats gas depends on your rates and the IRA credit, which the ranking above reflects.
When gas still wins
Where gas is cheap relative to electricity, a gas option can win over 10 years. At your rates the electric heat pump still comes out ahead, but the gap shrinks as electricity gets pricier.
Climate and the cold-water penalty
In Zone 3, incoming water is about 62°F, so every option works harder to reach 120°F. Cold also derates the heat pump: its rated COP drops to an effective 3.5 here, which is built into the numbers above.
The Real Question: Cheapest to Install, or Cheapest to Own?
A water heater is one of the few appliances where the cheapest option to buy is often the most expensive to own. A standard electric resistance tank is the lowest sticker price on the shelf, but it turns one unit of electricity into one unit of heat, so it runs up the highest energy bill year after year.
A heat pump water heater flips that. It moves heat from the surrounding air into the tank instead of generating it, so it delivers three to four units of heat per unit of electricity. It costs more upfront, but the 30% federal credit narrows that gap, and the low running cost usually makes it the cheapest to own over a 10-year life. Gas options sit in between, and where gas is cheap relative to electricity, they can still win.
This calculator does not assume a winner. It runs the same hot-water demand through all four options at your actual rates and climate, then ranks them by total cost so you can see which is cheapest to own for your situation, not the national average.
How Efficiency Is Measured (UEF and COP)
Tanks and tankless units are rated by Uniform Energy Factor (UEF), the DOE measure of how much of the energy they consume ends up in the hot water. A standard gas storage tank is around 0.60 UEF; a condensing gas tankless is around 0.90; an electric resistance tank is around 0.92.
A heat pump water heater is measured differently because it can exceed 100% efficiency: it is rated by Coefficient of Performance (COP), typically 3.0 to 4.0. A COP of 3.5 means it delivers 3.5 units of heat per unit of electricity. That is the whole reason it can be the cheapest to run even when electricity costs more per unit of energy than gas.
COP falls in cold air, so this calculator derates the heat pump for your climate zone rather than using the best-case rated number.
The Federal Credit and What Qualifies
The IRA Section 25C credit covers 30% of the installed cost of a qualifying ENERGY STAR heat pump water heater, capped at $2,000 per year and available through 2032. On a $2,500 install, that is $750 off. It is nonrefundable, so you need to owe federal income tax to claim it.
Standard gas and electric storage tanks do not qualify. A high-efficiency gas water heater with a UEF of 0.95 or higher can claim a smaller credit of up to $600, but typical units do not meet that bar, so this calculator does not apply it automatically. Check the DSIRE database (dsireusa.org) for state and utility rebates, which can stack on top of the federal credit.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which water heater is cheapest: heat pump, tankless, gas, or electric?
It depends on your local electricity and gas rates, your household size, and your climate. As a rule of thumb, a heat pump water heater is usually the cheapest to run because it delivers 3 to 4 units of heat per unit of electricity, and after the 30% IRA credit it often has the lowest total cost too. But where natural gas is cheap relative to electricity, a gas tankless or gas storage tank can win over a 10-year horizon. A standard electric resistance tank is the cheapest to install but almost always the most expensive to operate. This calculator ranks all four at your actual rates so you can see which wins for you.
What is the federal tax credit for a heat pump water heater?
The IRA Section 25C credit covers 30% of the installed cost of a qualifying ENERGY STAR heat pump water heater, capped at $2,000 per year. It is a nonrefundable credit, so you must owe federal income tax to use it, and it is available through 2032. Standard gas and electric storage tanks do not qualify. A high-efficiency gas water heater (UEF of 0.95 or higher) can claim a smaller credit of up to $600, but most units do not meet that threshold, so this calculator does not apply it automatically.
Do heat pump water heaters work in cold climates?
Yes, but their efficiency drops in cold spaces because they pull heat from the surrounding air. A unit rated at COP 3.5 in a warm garage might deliver an effective COP closer to 2.5 in an unheated basement in a cold climate. This calculator derates the heat pump COP by your climate zone, the same way our heat pump heating calculator does. They also slightly cool and dehumidify the space they sit in, which is a bonus in summer and a small penalty in winter if that space is heated.
Is a tankless water heater worth the extra cost?
A tankless (on-demand) unit never runs out of hot water and avoids the standby losses of keeping a full tank hot, so it runs a bit cheaper than a comparable storage tank on the same fuel. But it costs more to install, especially a gas tankless that needs upgraded venting and a larger gas line. Whether the operating savings recover that premium depends on your usage and rates, which is exactly what the 10-year comparison above shows.
How is the operating cost calculated?
The energy to heat water is its weight times the temperature rise: gallons used per day times 8.34 pounds per gallon times the difference between the incoming cold-water temperature and your setpoint, summed over the year. That useful heat is divided by each unit's efficiency (the DOE Uniform Energy Factor for tanks and tankless, or the effective COP for the heat pump) to get the energy it actually consumes, then multiplied by your electricity or gas rate. Colder climates have colder incoming water, so every option uses more energy there.
Related reading: Home Electrification Payback Calculator, for electrifying the whole house.
Disclaimer: This calculator is for educational and illustrative purposes only. Efficiency values (UEF and COP) and the climate-based inlet-water and COP adjustments are typical averages and may not reflect your specific equipment, installation space, or microclimate. Energy rates, equipment costs, incentives, and tax credits change. The federal IRA 25C credit requires a qualifying ENERGY STAR unit and that you owe federal income tax. Installed costs vary by contractor, venting, and electrical or gas service. Nothing on this page constitutes financial, tax, or energy advice. See our full disclaimer.
For educational and illustrative purposes only. Not financial, tax, or investment advice. Results depend on the accuracy of your inputs and on assumptions that may not reflect your actual situation. ForestMatters, LLC is not a registered investment advisor. Full disclaimer.
Related Tools
Heat Pump vs Gas Furnace Calculator
Heating is the bigger energy decision in the same house. Compare a heat pump against a gas furnace on full cost.
Home Electrification Payback Calculator
Electrifying more than the water heater? See the combined payback across every gas-to-electric upgrade.
Solar ROI Calculator
A heat pump water heater runs on electricity. Pairing it with solar can cut or erase that operating cost.